Sam Harris: Religions Are Failed Sciences | Big Think
443,943
2011-07-07に共有
New videos DAILY: bigth.ink/youtube
Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: bigth.ink/Edge
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We are misled by the very term "religion," argues Sam Harris. Religion was simply the discourse humans used when all causes in the universe were opaque.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SAM HARRIS:
Sam Harris is the author of the New York Times bestsellers, The End of Faith and Letter to a Christian Nation. The End of Faith won the 2005 PEN Award for Nonfiction.
Mr. Harris' writing has been published in over ten languages. He and his work have been discussed in Newsweek, TIME, The New York Times, Scientific American, Rolling Stone, and many other journals. His writing has appeared in Newsweek, The Los Angeles Times, The Times (London), The Boston Globe, The Atlantic, Nature, The Annals of Neurology, and elsewhere.
Mr. Harris is a graduate in philosophy from Stanford University and holds a PhD in neuroscience from UCLA, where he studied the neural basis of belief with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). He is also a Co-Founder and CEO of Project Reason.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TRANSCRIPT:
Question: What is religion?
Sam Harris: Well I think we are misled by this very term “religion”. We use that word “religion” as though it meant a distinct thing . . . as though it meant one phenomenon in human discourse. And there’s really a range of infatuations and practices that go by the name of religion. And therefore many points on this continuum don’t have much in common with others. So if you take a religion like “Jainism” – a religion in India – its core principle is non-violence. Now there is where Gandhi got his conception of non-violence. And the Jains are vegetarian. They have no doctrine of holy war. In fact, they don’t even have a doctrine – a proper doctrine of self-defense. I mean they’re pacifists. They don’t want to hurt a fly. And then on the other end of the continuum, you have something like Islam where it has explicitly a doctrine of holy war, and a notion of . . . Combat and death, in certain contexts, is actually the highest obligation a religious person can fulfill. So these are both religions. And so religion is a word like “sport”. You have a sport like badminton, and you have a sport like, you know, boxing. They’re not . . . they’re both sports that, you know, one is much more dangerous. So I’m concerned . . . I’m obviously more concerned about religions like Islam that . . . wherein you have this marriage of a variety of spiritual and ethical concerns; but also certain kinds of metaphysical certainties that inspire people to not only die, but to kill others in the process. And you don’t have that in other religions. So I think that we have to be clear about how this term religion can mislead us.
Question: Why do we need religion?
I view religions as essentially failed sciences. I mean religion was the discourse that we had when all causes in the universe were opaque. We didn’t know . . . We didn’t know the basis of anything. We didn’t know why we were here. We didn’t know how diseases spread, or what disease was. We didn’t know how people . . . why people died early, and why others flourished. We don’t know what’s causing thunderstorms, or what’s causing crops to fail. And we very naturally . . . As a cognitive and behavioral imperative, we formed descriptions of the world, and we tried to figure out what’s going on. We tell ourselves stories about our origins, and about where we’re going, and about causes in the world. And those stories, given our just pervasive ignorance and our disposition to see agency in the world . . . to see, you know . . . to feel ourselves in relationship to the world, these stories entail being in relation to invisible friends and enemies. And so we have this parent figure in the sky who’s gonna take care of things if you live rightly. And we have other demonic presences that we should be really worried about. And gradually, what you see happening is that religion . . . As rationality and dozens of specific sciences were birthed in the human conversation, you see religion on a hundred fronts losing the argument with science. And then we see it on the front of human health and disease. Religion . . . You know, it used to be that you could get a diagnosis of demonic possession. That was a, you know, a reasonable thing to believe you had if you were having seizures. You know, but now we have a science of neurology, and we have a science of epilepsy. And so when your kid has seizures, you know, you don’t go to...
Read the full transcript at bigthink.com/videos/religions-are-failed-sciences
コメント (21)
-
Want to get Smarter, Faster? Subscribe for DAILY videos: bigth.ink/GetSmarter
-
It kills me to think how much tormenting existed in those times when the book of Leviticus, Deuteronomy, etc. were the principle in understanding nature. It's hard to think how much a child must've mentally and/or physically suffered when a priest claimed it to be possessed by demons and demanded to go under exorcism, which was actually just the unfortunate case of epilepsy. And people still today question "what has science done for us?. Hmm.. I don't know
-
"Religion was invented when the first con man met the first fool." MT
-
Facts serve us well when we combat wishful thinking. We need more clear, honest, brave, intelligent, curious voices like Sam.
-
"We will understand Spiritual Experience so well at some point" When this happens, I wonder what we will do with such knowledge. Interesting.
-
Honesty is tough to come by these days.
-
I'm a hardcore atheist but also very spiritual. I love to meditate and reach or unlock deep parts of my brain but I do not contribute these spiritual experiences to a higher power.
-
Religion guesses at things, writes it down, and when shown to be wrong, has a temper tantrum. Blasphemy laws are passed to prevent Divine Beings from losing arguments with mere mortals like Mr Harris.
-
Failed sciences... I've never thought of it like that. Very interesting.
-
Atheism is an illusion caused by lack of alcohol. I seen god yesterday through the bottom of my pint glass - Hic!
-
Maybe the human race will grow up someday!
-
Thank you for sharing your thoughts ;) I totally agree. I also have "spiritual" experiences as an atheist :) I only understand that it has nothing to do with some "father figure" or anything else, but it doesn't make it less magical to experience.
-
Wish i could of heard something like this when I was 13, would of eliminated a lot of fear. Im attempting to raise my kids with a knowledge of religion but not a belief in it..
-
Sam Harris, thank you for sharing this with us. Helps me walk away from Religion. I planned it, but now, I know I have to.
-
As an epileptic, this makes me smile.
-
I am suprised, if morality is subjective then why criticize Islam
-
Remember this guy is a P.hD holder in Neuroscience and expert in religion, at least he got balls to say what has to be said about a particular community. This guy is a legend!
-
i agree with this guy
-
I love that legitimate arguments can take place on a social website's comments. Some agree, and some disagree, and justified evidence is used to trump over covered hysteria. To me, that is beautiful.
-
Badminton is one of the biggest killers out there
