Jesus is God? AI debates Christian vs. Muslim

737,299

15,344 0

2024-06-08に共有

I configured Muslim and Christian AIs (large language models) to engage in a debate over one of the most controversial topics in religious discourse: the divinity of Jesus Christ. Watch as these advanced LLMs bring unique perspectives and arguments to the table, challenging beliefs and shedding light on a topic that has sparked theological discussions for centuries.

To make it even more interesting, I've included 14 different AI models from some of the largest companies in the world to judge each response. It'll be fascinating to see if there's any bias in their evaluations and how they each interpret the arguments.

Leave your thoughts in the comments.
If you enjoy the video, please consider hitting the like button, and subscribing with notifications for more.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Round One: Is Jesus God or Just a Prophet?
0:28 Quran Denies Jesus’ Divinity (Sura Al-Ma'idah 5: 72)
0:52 Jesus' Prayer Shows Human Nature (Matthew 26: 39)
1:21 Jesus’ Birth Highlights God’s Power (Sura Al-Imran 3: 59)
1:47 Jesus’ Incarnation for Salvation (Philippians 2: 6-8)
2:19 God’s Uniqueness Precludes Human Form (Sura Al-Ikhlas 112: 4)
2:44 Jesus’ Humanity Reveals God’s Love (Hebrews 2: 14-17)
3:15 God Forgives Without Incarnation (Sura Az-Zumar 39: 53)
3:40 Justice and Atonement in Jesus’ Sacrifice (Romans 3: 25-26)
4:10 Balance of Justice and Mercy (Sura An-Nisa 4: 110)
4:39 Perfect Atonement Required for Sin (Hebrews 9: 22)
5:08 Mercy Without Sacrifice (Sura Az-Zumar 39: 53)
5:34 Defeating Sin and Death Through Sacrifice (Romans 6: 23)
6:09 Direct Forgiveness Demonstrates Mercy (Sura An-Nisa 4: 48)
6:36 Sacrifice Shows Depth of God’s Love (Philippians 2: 9-11)

Round Two
7:25 Jesus’ Miracles by God’s Permission (Sura Al-Ma'idah 5: 110)
7:53 Jesus' Authority to Forgive Sins (Matthew 9: 6)
8:20 Authority Given, Not Independent (John 5: 30)
8:54 Trinitarian Relationship (Philippians 2: 6-7)
9:24 Humility and Submission (John 14: 10)
9:53 Fullness of Deity in Jesus (Colossians 2: 9)
10:20 Presence and Power, Not Divinity (John 14: 10)
10:47 Unity Within the Trinity (John 10: 30)
11:09 Unity in Purpose, Not Essence (John 14: 28)
11:35 Incarnate Role and Pre-existence (John 17: 5)
12:08 Pre-ordained Mission (Matthew 27: 46)
12:36 Human Experience and Worship (John 20: 28)
13:02 Role in God’s Plan (Matthew 4: 10)
13:30 Worthy of Worship (Hebrews 1: 6)

Round Three
14:06 Pre-existence, Not Divinity (John 5: 30)
14:42 Claim to Divinity (John 8: 58)
15:13 Metaphoric Language (John 10: 34-36)
15:53 Seeing the Father (John 14: 9)
16:26 Unique Role, Not Divinity (Sura Al-Ma'idah 5: 72)
17:14 Unity with God (Hebrews 1: 8)
17:47 Unity in Mission (Sura Al-Ma'idah 5: 72)
18:32 Biblical Affirmations of Divinity (John 1: 1)
19:06 Highlighting Unique Role (Sura An-Nisa 4: 171)
19:49 Divine Nature and Identity (John 1: 18)
20:22 Correction of Distortions (Sura Al-Baqarah 2: 79)
21:06 Divine Inspiration (2 Timothy 3: 16)
21:44 Restoration of Monotheism (Sura Al-Imran 3: 3)
***

コメント (21)

@JonOleksiuk 1ヶ月前

Was the New Testament Corrupted? (NEW DEBATE VIDEO) https://youtu.be/EkiLOWPdDAg Atheism vs. Theism https://youtu.be/EMyAGuHnDHk Don't forget to subscribe and hit the bell so you don't miss the next debate :) I'd love to hear your suggestions below.
@lovespeaks777 1ヶ月前

But they never got mad and screamed at each other 😂😂
@Christ_TheWay 1ヶ月前

Muslims quote the Bible while also claiming that the Bible is corrupt.
@Yipper64 14日前

One thing I notice with this debate is if a real Christian and Muslim where to debate like this, when the Christian quotes scripture the Muslim would say "but the scripture is invalid because it was mistranslated" or you know, whatever it is they specifically say. Essentially a Muslim wouldnt let it be used as an argument. Not to mention how two people will often try to drive the conversation towards a point they can make their strongest point while glossing over the weaker points. Whereas LLMs are specifically made to never steer the conversation in a different direction.
@mdg72584 14日前

I find this fascinating. Try using the original Hebrew as input to see if the interpretation comes out the same. There is a lot of debate on if what we read in English is the intended translation or if something else was said instead. When the AI emphasizes a specific word, I always wonder if the original was written that way or if it was an interpretation
@jasonhubbard7409 1ヶ月前

This was amazing. They didn’t even call each other Hitler. Not even once. …I didn’t know online debate could do that.
@neufeldethan 1ヶ月前

This can’t be a Muslim AI. It didn’t interrupt and turn away the question
@ankelos913 9日前

Fascinating! Enjoyed it from beginning to end.
@matrixlife3512 21日前

A major shortcoming of this method is the AI does not account for how reliable the text is based on a chain of custody back to the source. As such apocrypha text written by men is treated at the same level of trust as a watertight accurate transmission through well-known sources
@Noxictyz 1ヶ月前

Please do another where the AI' can argue with historical and archelogical evidence outside the texts. Allow the christian ai to use early church fathers and the cathecism and the muslim to use hadiths.
@christianeddins2904 1ヶ月前

Notice how 90% of the conversation relies on Muslim Ai attacking authenticity of the Bible whilst Christian AI is mainly in defense. The foundation of the argument seems to be based on the Bible which is interesting. I would like to see the algorithm switch roles and add some offence from Christian AI on authenticity of the Quran as the main foundation of the Argument.
@kikisambudi4274 13日前

thats not debate, you just played a recorder
@ByzantineMonk 14日前

how did you train these LLM? how did you train the third unbiased judge IA?
@teklittewelde1487 1ヶ月前

The difference between Christian and Muslim is that the God of Christian is limitless and all powerful. He can be a human and God at the same time, but the God of islam can not be human and God at the same time because he is not all powerful.
@kujo734 1ヶ月前

How can the koran know more about Jesus when it was written 600 years after He lived? The New Testament was written by first-hand eyewitnesses.
@WorldEmbraceOfficial 21日前

Thanks, Jon, for your excellence in presenting in the most creative ways TRUTH
@EthanMeraz-zd3ul 13日前

Hey Jon, you've done a good job! I just wanted to ask if there is any way to add to the AI knowledge from Christian arguments from history, from the church fathers (i.e. apostolic fathers, Justin Martyr, Irenaeus of Lyons, Tertullian, Basil, Chrysostom, Augustine, etc.) to later saints from every part of Christianity (i.e. Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant) whether it be Thomas Aquinas, Erasmus, Luther, Calvin, Gregory Palamas, etc or even use various councils, creeds, or confessions. And finally, maybe even have them dialogue with one another, that is the different denominations of Christianity.
@jimmahbee 1ヶ月前

There’s one small problem… The Bible clearly says, and it was written before the Quran that if we are an angel preach any other message any other gospel let them be acursed… this is exactly what happened with the Muslim faith… While in a cave, Mohammed, was accosted by supposedly the Angel Gabriel, and given a new gospel. this completely contradicts what was just written
@deezn2856 1ヶ月前

JESUS CHRIST IS THE TRUTH!!! ✝️✝️✝️
@kazuha74 11日前

awesome video! So cool to see Ai put to good use 😊