What's The Largest Sofa That Can Fit Around a Corner?

Sign up to Brilliant to receive a 20% discount with this link! brilliant.org/upandatom/ Recommended course: Advanced Geometry Puzzles brilliant.org/courses/advanced-geometry-puzzles/

I tried to explain this problem to my friend, but he continued to scream things like "I'm not interested!", "I don't care about math!" or "Nobody asked you to cut off the edges of my sofa!"

Seems like the problem now is less "can you find a bigger sofa?" and more "can you finalize the proof for Gerver's sofa?"

I'm Swedish, so my solution is of course to disassemble the sofa and bring it through in pieces. IKEA beats math every time.

4:02 sofa we've just been guessing at shapes

I gotta say as someone who worked for a moving company as a grunt for years, I find this fascinating. But it's not really the problem in the real world as we have 3 dimensions and most places have upwards of 12 foot ceilings. So you flip whatever your moving up on a side and then rotate it around, of course this breaks down and becomes complicated when the 90° turn is in the middle of a stairwell but there's ways to work it out. Even without touching the walls ( we put that to the test moving one family out and another into a place that was freshly painted so we couldn't touch a single wall) it's difficult but do able. The real problem is doorways.. like moving a L shaped couch that isn't sectional through a doorway into a hallway. Fun stuff Lol

On a fun note: Yes if you give the property of disassembly, there do exist a plethora of larger objects/sofa that can move over the hallway. Ikea still lurks around because of this.

I thoroughly enjoyed the Numberphile video on this problem. When I saw you had posted one on the same topic I was skeptical you could add anything worthwhile to the discussion. I was wrong to doubt you! Your explanation of how a balanced shape has no space to gain through small movements was really intuitive! Your ability to turn a complex and difficult to explain concept into something easy is on another level. You are a terrific science educator!

This is such an incredibly elegant example of how math is actually done in real life. I wish all the students who “hate math” could see and really internalize this. Math isn’t about solving equations (although you gotta get your hands dirty sometimes) it’s about finding new perspectives and massaging hard problems into successively more tractable ones

I didn't think a degree in mathematics was needed to to become a furniture mover. This is why sectional sofas exist.

Shout out to the Douglas Adams fans who remember Richard Macduff’s staircase sofa. Stuck ever since delivery men couldn’t get it round a corner but then couldn’t get it back out the way it came either

We moved a large oak desk (with no real effort) into our home office. When it came time to move the desk out we found it impossible to get back out as the doorway was narrow and led to a 90 degree hallway. Ended up sawing the legs off the desk to get it out. Still confounds me how we managed to get it in with no real problem.

Always a pleasure to be an audience in your family, Jade! I have been studying optimization in CS for my degree for 3 years now (about to graduate in the next summer!), and your content like this manages to tickle that little tone of fancy in my heart for math and provokes me to admire the hidden beauty that most often goes rather disappointingly unnoticed. But, I believe content creators like you, Derek, Diana, Henry, Brady, Grant (just to name a few) are always there to keep igniting those burning little sparks of curiosity ... Keep going and never forget that enthusiasts like me are always watching (in awe) the essense and value you bring upon in our community. Cheers :)

What makes the sofa problem even more complex is that you can rotate the sofa in a 3rd dimension (pitch, yaw, and roll as they name them in aviation). Additionally, real life sofas can also squish at the edges and corners. Sofas are so complicated 😂

Douglas Adams brought up a similar problem in his story " Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency ". In this case it was a corner half way up some stairs, the movers got it to the corner, rotated it all over and then couldn't get it out in any direction. It was stuck. ( The use of a time and space machine finally solved it but that part is different to this puzzle...

6:24 "sofa we've been..."

This is the best mathematical puzzle I've ever seen ! Such a simple puzzle yet difficult and quite an elegant solution !

That was very enjoyable with great graphics. A stuck sofa also plays an important part in Douglas Adams "Holistic Detection agency". There, a computer simulation proved it could not be freed by going backwards or forwards. For the resolution of this paradox, read the novel. 🙂

Fun topic! I've seen Numberphile tackle this topic but the part where you showed how lateral movement of the hall allows for an increase in area was really cool!

This problem also looks like minkowski sums and differences! Very useful for checking for intersections and getting resulting shapes efficiently. And the intuition of "draw a vector along another vectors path." Looks similar if not the same to drawing the shape of no collisions when drawn along a path! 😀