Why Is Most Christian Music So BAD? | The Catholic Talk Show

I was an evangelical worship pastor who recently converted to Catholicism. What you said about the lack of substance of the Eucharist to guide the music is spot on. There is no sacramental worldview in evangelical churches but there’s a craving for it, and so the music becomes this thing that attempts to bring this transcendental climax instead of the body and blood of Jesus.

You’ve described the South Park episode where Cartman starts a Christian rock band called Faith Plus One.

When I listen to Gregorian chant, no explanations are necessary.

Byzantine and Gregorian chants are the best types of Christian music in my opinion.

Name of the Hillsong concert video? I love the duet w/ Matt Maher and Audrey Assad (“Lord, I need you”). Audrey’s harmony 🥰🥰 in that song

Lecrae is Christian rap. Mercy Me, Kutlass, Casting Crowns, For King and Country are my favorites.

Love this podcast!

The Gloria should not sound like a Disney Princess movie theme song, just sayin'. I need chant, Mozart, Palestrina, etc...

This has easily become my favorite podcast on YouTube! Love the content! 🙏🏼💯❤️

Zack williams, 12 stones, kutless, casting crowns, Matt Maher who is catholic are some of my favorite.

As a former Protestant and now Catholic for 5 years this brings back bad memories.

DEAREST BELOVED IN CATHOLIC TALK SHOW I NEED UNCONDITIONAL LOVE AND PRAYERS FROM THE THREE OF YOU I REALLY LOVE SOME OF YOUR TALK SHOW VERY MUCH I THANK YOU FOR THE LAUGHTER AND SHARING

And what about Good Catholic Music??? Throwing my recommendation of Catholic Lofi Youtube Channel via Matt Fradd

Thank you for your past podcasts. I hope both my sons are subscribers, but they are their own men. ❤️😀

I've been yearning for Christian music that was actually pleasant to listen to. Not only did I find the last song (the best), & the jazzy song to be examples of songs I want, I'm going to look for albums. The Gregorian chant was very moving and I could see myself gardening or cooking listening to it, got to get these. Since my reversion a few years ago, a lot of what I used to listen to, doesn't do it for me any more. This was one of my favorite shows to date. On that note, you all stopped showing up in my feed, so I'm way behind I hope listening to several episodes today will put you back in there. PS If any of you guys read this, do you have a show on good Christian novels? Are there any? I'm a book hound and all I read for decades were murder mysteries with a pagan theme. I found one book I like several years ago, I think it was the Wishing Bridge or something like that. It ended up being a Christian book instead of pagan and I loved it. Sure could use some good tips. Anyone?

"is this what protestants do?" Took me out 😂

Hank Hill said it best: “Christian rock doesn’t make church music better, it just makes tock and roll worse.” 😂

That first one was brilliant 🤣, definitely worthy of a Grammy.

Man o man! Shout out to ol padre there with the trap mix omg (gosh)...lol I love it! Speaks to my chill step vibes i like when I am working....I am so playing this at work :)

For King and Country and Casting Crowns are awesome 👍 groups!!